Sarbjit Singh*
Assistant Professor in Public Administration, Guru Gobind
Singh College, Sanghera (Barnala)
Corresponding Author
Email: kularsarbjit@gmail.com
INTRODUCTION:
The Integrated Child Development Services
(ICDS) Scheme is one of the flagship programmes of the Government of India and
represents one of the world's largest and unique programmes for early childhood
care and development. It is the foremost symbol of country's commitment to its
children, pregnant women and nursing mothers, as a response to the challenge of
providing pre-school non-formal education on one hand and breaking the vicious
cycle of malnutrition, morbidity, reduced learning capacity and mortality on
the other. It was launched on 2nd October 1975, on the auspicious
occasion of the 106th birth anniversary of Mahatma Gandhi, the
Father of the Nation1. In the initial stages ICDS was implemented in
33 selected community development blocks all over India. ICDS has expanded considerably in subsequent
years and Up to 31st March 2013; there are 7076 sanctioned projects,
7025 operational projects in India. In Punjab ICDS program has expanded very
rapidly. At present, there are 155 sanctioned and 154 operational projects2
Vijay Rattan3 is his book (1997) gave details about genesis,
growth, components of ICDS and described a package of seven services comprising
supplementary nutrition, immunization, health check-ups, and referral services’
treatment of illness, Nutrition and health education and non-formal pre-school
education which are provided under ICDS. Manisha Jain4 rightly pointed out that the objectives of the ICDS
mission would be to institutionalize essential services and strengthen
structure at all level.
There is a plan to roll out strengthened and restructured ICDS in three
years beginning with 200 high burden districts in the first years 2012-2013 and
so on.
Nutrition and Health Education (NHED) component of ICDS scheme for Women
has the long‐term
goal of capacity building of women in the age group of 15‐45 years especially Pregnant women and Nursing women, so that they can
look after their own health, nutrition and development needs as well as that of
their children and families. The main objective of education in nutrition is to
help individual to establish food habits and practices that are consistent with
the nutritional needs of the body and adapted to the cultural pattern and food
resources of the area in which they live. Nutrition and Health Education
comprises basic health, nutrition and development information related to
childcare and development, infant feeding practices, utilization of health
services, family planning and environmental sanitation, maternal nutrition,
ante‐natal care,
prevention and management of diarrhoea, acute respiratory infections and other
common infections of children.5 Health and Nutrition education is
delivered by Anganwadi workers (AWW) and ANMs through
inter‐personal contacts and
discussions at Anganwadi (literally meaning “the
courtyard”) Centres (AWC). Each Anganwadi usually covers a population of 400 to 800 in
rural and urban areas and 300 to 800 in tribal and hilly areas. An
important contact point is established with the nursing mothers to educate them
about services for children like taking
care and monitoring of child’s growth, timely immunization, knowledge about
breast feeding, colostrum feeding, treatment of
diarrhoea/minor illness, not to provide home‐made medicines during illness, preparation of nutritious food/feeding
practices, importance of education of the child, about cleanliness and hygiene,
preparation of oral dehydration solution, care of severely malnourished
children. Services for Mother provided are bout immunization during pregnancy,
about institutional delivery, about feeding practices during pregnancy and
lactating period, Iron-Folic Acid (IFA) supplementation, about correct posture
during pregnancy, correct posture during breastfeeding, about self-care and
health, about diseases illness, about nipple hygiene, purification of water to
mothers and adolescent girls, small family norms, etc.6
But, Ajay Kumar, Monika Singh and KuldeepBauddh7 (2010)
presented very grim realities saying that every sixth malnourished child in
India lives in U.P., about 56% children born to illiterate mother were under
weight, every second adolescent girls was anemic,
about 49% women was below 45 kgs, less than 3%
mothers received the minimum full dosage of Iron, Folic acid tablets, only one
in 20 new born was put to the breast within the first hours of birth and 23%
mother undergo health check-up after delivery. Dongre8 (2008) found
that poor co-operation from villages, mothers do not follow medical advice,
mothers are busy with from work, irregular and poor health check-up services,
mother do not follow dietary advices, poor personal hygiene of families, poor
environmental sanitation and poor child care practices etc. are most common
reasons for the limited success of ICDS programme.
In the background of these
observations, it is very important to investigate the relevance and
effectiveness of the world`s largest and most unique ICDS programme. So, this
field study carried out in the Barnala district of Punjab
to examine the impact of NHED of ICDS on the
nursing women in terms of enhancing their knowledge in the critical Health Care
areas like, health check-up, immunization, nutrition care of children and
women, prevention of nutritional deficiency diseases, etc. and the extent to
which the nursing women put this knowledge into practice.
MATERIALS AND
METHODS:
The present study was
conducted in all three ICDS project: Barnala, Sehna and Mehal Kalan of the Barnala District of
Punjab. The study was conducted during August to December 2012. A total of 30
villages (10 from each ICDS project) were selected on the basis of random. From
each village 2 nursing women were selected randomly. Thus a total of 60 nursing
women were in the sample, from all 30 villages which were having Anganwadi for at least the last 25 years, as such nursing
women are expected to avail the NHED service of ICDS scheme. These women were
interviewed by house to house survey using interview schedule consisting of
close ended question.
FINDINGS:
Keeping in view the specific objective, personal
interviews with nursing mothers were conducted. Interviews and observations
brought important facts to light. The results are presented in the tabular form
below.
In the present investigation as described in Table 1,
about 20% of deliveries had taken place at home and also they were attended by
untrained dais. The deliveries of about 58.33% women had taken place at primary
health centres/sub centres
and government hospitals and these were performed by government health staff.
The deliveries of 21.66% women had taken place at private hospitals and the
same were attended to by private health staff.
It was sad to find that 41.66% women did not go to any of
proper places for the deliveries.
According to the laid down system, normally the mother
and the baby should have two health check-ups within 7-10 days of delivery for
their well-being and to prevent infection. Table 2 shows a shocking result that
a high majority (80%) of the women did not undergo any health check-up after
the delivery.
Table
1:Where was the child born? Who gave you maternity assistance at
the time of delivery? (Nursing Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan ICDS Project |
||
|
Home/ un trained Dai |
03(15) |
04(20) |
05(25) |
12(20.00) |
|
PHC/sub centres and Govt. Health staff. |
16(80) |
08(40) |
11(55) |
35(58.33) |
|
Private hospital,Private health staff |
01(05) |
08(40) |
04(20) |
13(21.66) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in brackets are percentages.
Table
2: Did you get regular health check-up
after delivery? If yes, where waslast health check-up
done? (Nursing Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan ICDS Project |
||
|
PHC/sub centre/Govt.
Hospital |
04(20) |
01(05) |
03(15) |
08(13.33) |
|
Private hospital |
01(05) |
01(05) |
02(10) |
04(06.66) |
|
Anganwadi Centre |
------ |
----- |
------ |
------------ |
|
No
health check-up conducted. |
15(75) |
18(90) |
15(75) |
48(80.00) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in brackets are percentages.
Table 3: Have you received Supplementary Nutrition food
from AWC? If yes, did you consume the given food?(Nursing Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan ICDS Project |
||
|
All
consumed |
02(10) |
01(05) |
05(25) |
08(13.33) |
|
Some
consumed |
05(25) |
06(30) |
04(20) |
15(25.00) |
|
Did
not consume |
------- |
------ |
------- |
---------- |
|
Did
not receive at all |
13(65) |
13(65) |
11(55) |
37(61.66) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in brackets are percentages.
Only 20% women got their health check-up after delivery.
Out of them 13.33% of the nursing women underwent the check up at primary
health centres/sub centres
or Governmental hospitals and merely four(6.66%) women
underwent this check-up at such private hospital which was not a proper place
for check-up. This indicates a sorry state of affairs.
The government of India has laid
down that NW are eligible to receive SN ration for six months of delivery from
AWCs. In the Table 3,it was appalling to note that
majority (61.66%) women did not receive any SN ration from AWCs. Overall, 38.33%
women received SN ration from AWCs. Out of them, only some(13.33%)
women consumed all food given by AWWs and about 25% women consumed some part of
the given food. On further probing, it was found that it was due to various
reasons such as it was hard to digest, was not tasty, was of poor quality or
was not cooked properly.
Immunization is ensured by providing BCG, DPT, Polio and
measles vaccines as necessary to the child. They prevent young child from six
child-killer diseases like measles, diphtheria, whooping cough, tuberculosis,
poliomyelitis and tetanus. The Government of India began the process to bring
awareness to the parents about the need for child vaccination. This message is
reinforced by AWWs, ANWs, television and radio advertisements, by newspapers,
posters and public address systems and by all the communication resources at
the local level. In the present study as explained in the Table 4, found that a
majority (75%) of the nursing women did not know about the different types of
child vaccinations. Only 25% women have proper awareness and knowledge about
child vaccinations. Thus, the awareness and knowledge about child vaccination in
NW is considered to be inadequate.
Measles is caused by minute particles or viruses which
are only visible under the electronic microscope. It is highly infectious and
can spread by droplets from the nose or throat of infected children. A perusal
of the data of table 5 indicates that, a high majority (85%)
women replied that they did not have proper knowledge about the cause of
measles. Some (11.66%) nursing women correctly replied that measles occurred
due to some virus infection. Merely two (3.33%) women felt that it occurred due
to some deficiency.
Table 4: Did you know about the type of
vaccination to be given to a child up-to three years of age? (Nursing
Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan
ICDS Project |
||
|
Yes |
05(20) |
05(15) |
05(20) |
15(25.00) |
|
No |
15(80) |
15(85) |
15(80) |
45(75.00) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in
brackets are percentages.
Table 5:
What causes Measles? (Nursing Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan ICDS Project |
||
|
Due
to some infection. |
01(05) |
04(20) |
02 (20) |
07(11.66) |
|
Due
to some deficiency. |
01(05) |
01(05) |
------ |
02(03.33) |
|
Due
to some curse. |
------ |
----- |
----- |
-------------- |
|
Do
not know. |
18(90) |
15(75) |
18(80) |
51(85.00) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in brackets are percentages.
Table 6: How would
you treat Measles? (Nursing Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan ICDS Project |
||
|
Go to
a doctor and get vaccination. |
03(15) |
01(05) |
04(20) |
08(13.33) |
|
Use Neemleaves and other traditional medicine. |
06(30) |
13(65) |
07(35) |
26(43.33) |
|
Obeisance
at Shitala Mata Temple |
03(15) |
01(05) |
03(15) |
07(11.66) |
|
Did
not know |
08(40) |
05(25) |
06(30) |
19(31.66) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in
brackets are percentages.
Table 7: Do you know how to prepare ORS (Oral
Rehydration Solution)? If yes, who gave advice to you? (Nursing
Women)
|
Attributes |
Responses |
Responses of Total NW |
||
|
Barnala ICDS Project |
Sehna ICDS Project |
Mehal Kalan
ICDS Project |
||
|
Private
health staff |
----- |
01(05) |
03(15) |
04(06.66) |
|
Govt
Health Staff |
08(40) |
05(15) |
03(15) |
16(26.66) |
|
Anganwadi worker |
------ |
----- |
01(05) |
01(01.66) |
|
Did
not know |
12(60) |
14(80) |
13 (65) |
39(65.00) |
|
Total |
20 |
20 |
20 |
60(100) |
Source: Culled from Primary data. Figures in
brackets are percentages.
It was shocking to note that a large
number (88.33%) women did not have proper knowledge and awareness about
the main cause of measles which is the number one killer disease among the six
preventable diseases by vaccination. The awareness of nursing women cannot be
considered up to the mark in this regard.
For the purpose of treatment of measles, Table 6indicates
that only 13.33% of women reported that they went to a doctor for the treatment
of the measles; about 43.33% women answered that they treated the measles with neem leaves and other traditional medicines, some (11.66%)
of the women replied that they went to the Shitala
Mata Temple for the treatment of the measles, while 31.66% women did not have
awareness and knowledge about the treatment of the measles.
The findings again indicated that a large number (86.65%)
of the women were not sure about the correct way of managing measles. It is a
sorry state of affairs.
Replying to questions about knowledge as how to prepare
oral rehydration solution to prevent diarrheal diseases, which is the leading
cause of children’s deaths in India. The Table 7 shows shocking result that a majority (65%) women did not have any knowledge to prepare
oral rehydration solution. Only 35% of the nursing women reported that they
have skill to prepare oral rehydration solution. Out of them, some (6.66%)
women received advice to prepare the oral rehydration solution from private
health staff, 26.66% women received this skill from government health staff and
merely one (1.66%) woman received advice to prepare oral re-hydration solution
from Anganwadi workers. So the role of the AWWs was
very unsatisfactory regarding this activity.
A study on health and nutrition
education component of ICDS programme on nursing women in terms of enhancement
of their knowledge about child vaccination, nutritious food for children,
prevention of nutritional deficiency diseases, family size and family planning
etc., was analysed on 60 nursing women in rural area of Barnala
district of Punjab. It was found that about 20% women did not go to a
proper place for the child delivery and their deliveries had taken place at
home. The result from our finding is much better compared to the 50% deliveries
had taken place at home reported by Syed E. Mahmoodet9. (2012). A high majority (80%) of the nursing women did not
undergo any health check-up after the delivery.
It was sad to find that a majority (61.66%) nursing women did not
receive supplementary nutrition ration from AWCs due to various reasons like
lack of time, the uncalled for behaviour of AWWs and irregularity of
supplementary nutrition ration at AWCs.Contrary to the
present study, Sharma et al. (2013)10 observed from a study in Chhattisgarh that
71.73% of the nursing women received supplementary nutrition food from the
AWCs. A majority (75%) of the nursing
women did not know about the different types vaccinations to be given to child.
The position was good in Odisha
to compare present findings as Paul. B et
al. (2012)11 found that 50.9% of the nursing women were known
about the different types of routine vaccination of children. It
was shocking to note that 88.33% nursing women did not have awareness about the
main cause of measles. The findings also indicated that a high majority
(86.66%) of nursing women were not sure about the right way of managing
measles. A study conducted by SEDEM, New Delhi12 (2005) reported
that 61.6% women did not know what causes of measles and about 52.4% were not
sure about managing measles. A majority 65% of nursing women did not have any
knowledge to prepare oral re-hydration solution. Adequate measures, if taken,
to remove the deficiencies of ICDS scheme can make it an even more beneficial
program for the receptive population of rural Punjab.
CONCLUSION:
The results showed that the nursing women did not have adequate
knowledge and proper awareness about nutrition and health care areas related to
the children and women. In this regard,
it is recommended that Supervisors should be given the responsibility of
organising formal NHED sessions at regular intervals in AWCs under their
supervision. Continuous and effective monitoring by Child Development Project
Officers (CDPOs) and district officials, as also active participation of health
functionaries, can go a long way in the effective implementation of this
component. For group formation and collecting women at one place for NHED
sessions, locally popular social or recreational event or activity may be
organised. Utilisation of folk media needs to be included in the training
component of AWWs to strengthen their skills in imparting NHED effectively.
REFERENCE:
1.
T.Mamata and D.Sarada, Child Right,
Discovery Publishing House Pvt. Ltd., New Delhi, 2009, p. 6.
2.
Annual Report 2012-2013, Ministry of Women and Child Development, Government of
India, New Delhi, p. 223
3.
Vijay Rattan, Integrated Child Development Services
Program Administration, Vol-1, S. Chand and
Company Ltd., New Delhi, 1997.
4.
Manisha Jain, Strengthening and Restructuring of ICDS Scheme, Yojana,
Vol. 57, No. 1, January, 2013, pp. 64-65.
5.
Evaluation Report on
Integrated Child Development Services, Programme Evaluation
Organization, Planning Commission, Government of India, New Delhi, 2011, p.28.
6.
Ibid
7.
Ajay Kumar, Mokia
Singh and Kuldeep Bauddh, Women and Child Health profile in UtterPradesh, Kurukshetra,
Vol. 58, No. 4, February 2010, pp.24-26.
8.
Dongre, AR, Deshmukh, PR Garg, BS, Eliminating
Childhood Malnutrition: discussion with mother and Anganwadi
Workers, Journal of Health
studies. Vol. 1, No. 2-3, May- December 2008, pp.48-52.
9.
Syed E. Mahmood, Anurag Srivastava, Ved P. Shrotriya and Payal Mishra, Infant feeding practices in the rural
population of north India, Journal of Family and Community Medicine,
Vol. 19, No. 2, May-August 2012, pp.130-135.
10. M. Sharma, G.P. Soni, N.
Sharma, Assessment of Coverage of
Services among beneficiaries residing in area covered by selected Anganwadi in Urban Project 1 and 2 of Raipur City,
Community Medicine and Health Education, Volume 3, No. 1, January, 2013, pp. 4-8.
11.
B. Paul, M. Sen, M. Panda,
Effect of Maternal Education on Maternal Awareness and Adoption of Immunization
Services in Cuttack City, Indian Journal of Maternal and Child Health, Vol. 14,
No. 1, January-March 2012, pp. 2-8.
12.
Society for Economic Development and Environmental
Management, New Delhi, Quick Review of
Working of ICDS in Rajasthan, 2005.http://wcd.nic.in/icds.htm, accessed on 10th
January, 2010.
Received on 28.11.2014 Modified on 24.12.2014
Accepted on 07.01.2015
©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian
J. Nur. Edu. and Research 5(2): April-June
2015; Page229-233
DOI: 10.5958/2349-2996.2015.00045.2